My Guess on final Cylon

[Hokus]

After doing some research. I think the final one is Diana 'Hardball' Seelix. She is not in the Final Dinner Picture. has long hair since there were 2 figures with long hair on a picture 3 had drawn and she is on the base ship while all remaing 4 are in the fleet. On the new episode I saw a trailler where 3 says I want the 4 cylons in the fleet.
This is just a guess but I think its a close one.
:D

I want to add one more thing. As far as I recall all final 4 are from the new caprica resistance. not sure about the girl. but Diana was too. :D

[redwards95]

It's possible it's Seelix, but what's the payoff of making it her? We know very little about her character and she doesn't have any strong relationships to any of the major characters. Finding out she is a cylon would not change much of anything on the show. It would just remove one pilot and we'd have to have some other pilot take her place. The longer the mystery goes on, the more it seems to me that the final model has to be one of the most important characters in the show to justify the delayed reveal. We've passed the point where just any random character can turn out to be the missing cylon model imo.

[mariarilke]

True, Seelix is too insignificant for that "most coveted title of all time."

[Hokus]

Before Tory became a Cylon she was not a major character as well.

[genji2000]

Before Tory became a Cylon she was not a major character as well.

She was the president's right-hand woman. Fairly major.

[redwards95]

It's pretty clear after Revelations that this theory is wrong as are most others.

[Joe Beaudoin Jr.]

It's pretty clear after Revelations that this theory is wrong as are most others.

If Three is to be believed... which I don't.

As she said herself, information is the only thing she has to offer. So she's not going to put all her cards out on the table.

The Last Cylon is her ace in the hole. She's not going to out that one out, since she was correct in surmising that the Four would be executed. It took Kara Thrace to put a stop to it, after finding out about the rosetta stone that is her shiny new Viper.

[redwards95]

If Three is to be believed... which I don't.

As she said herself, information is the only thing she has to offer. So she's not going to put all her cards out on the table.

The Last Cylon is her ace in the hole. She's not going to out that one out, since she was correct in surmising that the Four would be executed. It took Kara Thrace to put a stop to it, after finding out about the rosetta stone that is her shiny new Viper.

If she knows the identity of the fifth and it's somebody in the fleet, wouldn't she have required that person be handed over or at least asked whether she wanted to before agreeing to the truce and going to Earth?

[Joe Beaudoin Jr.]

If she knows the identity of the fifth and it's somebody in the fleet, wouldn't she have required that person be handed over or at least asked whether she wanted to before agreeing to the truce and going to Earth?

Actually, no.

Because she had no idea whether the humans would turn on them once they jumped to Earth. (For all she knew, the civvie fleet could've jumped to another location and the Galactica could've launched a military assault without any civvie collateral damage.)

Also, the Watchtower Four are seemingly pro-human... The only one who jumped at the chance to meet the other Cylons was Tory. The rest of them stayed behind.

So... the Last Cylon is the ace in the hole.

Also, Tory probably told Three that they don't know who the fifth is, so it's easier for her to play on that.

After all, had all the Five been outed, she would have lost any advantage she had. She would no longer be needed and her life would be forfeit, should someone decide to take it.

Is it just me, or do I get the feeling that the other Cylons are just a bit leery of D'Anna? Particularly over the whole hostage situation/standoff?

[Shane]

Threes are unstable.

[afleaah]

Is it just me, or do I get the feeling that the other Cylons are just a bit leery of D'Anna? Particularly over the whole hostage situation/standoff?

to me only leoben seemed to have a problem with it...the rest of them didnt seem to care...he told roslin wat they were doin and agreed to bring baltar to talk d'anna down
like when the centurions were movin the rest of the hostages to kill them sharon was there sayin- move unless u rather we shoot u here

[cameraguyfresno]

My first guess a long time ago was Seelix too..Diana..twin of Apollo. And Leobin did say Adama was a cylon. So Seelix could be a long lost twin of Apollo. Based it on the mythological name and Leobin and her not being in the Last Supper photo. But it's Boomer. She meets all the conditions set forth for the fifth plus...she's much more compelling.